Skip to content

On Wall Street, Your Next Bonus May Depend on How You Use AI

One in four. That is the share of U.S. finance HR professionals who say their organization now ties raises, promotions, and bonuses to how well employees use AI, according to a survey released on October 14 by recruiting firm Selby Jennings. Another 30% say AI use now has to be disclosed in formal performance reviews.

The timing matters, because year-end reviews are getting underway and bonus checks follow soon after.

We read the full report, checked who was actually surveyed, and compared the results with other data on Wall Street pay. The change is smaller than some headlines suggest, but it is real.

25%
Tie raises, promotions and bonuses to AI proficiency
30%
Require AI use to be disclosed during performance reviews
42%
Have introduced guidelines for evaluating AI skills

What the Selby Jennings Survey Found

Reuters first reported the findings, describing nearly a quarter of financial firms as linking pay or promotion to AI skills.

The underlying AI Talent Pulse Report puts the figure at 25% and adds three related numbers.

Finding Share of respondents
Tied raises, promotions, and bonuses to AI proficiency 25%
Require employees to disclose AI use in formal performance reviews 30%
Created new guidelines for assessing employee AI skills 42%
Created new roles or departments to prove a return on AI spending 30%

Taken together, the numbers describe an industry that is building measuring tools before agreeing on what to measure.

The 42% figure is the one we would watch. Guidelines usually come before pay rules, so that number hints at where the 25% could head by the next review cycle.

The survey does not say how much of any bonus depends on AI, and none of the coverage we checked reported that detail either.

Who Was Actually Surveyed

Several headlines described the respondents as 500 executives or 500 companies. The methodology section of the report says something narrower.

Censuswide polled 500 U.S. HR professionals in the finance industry between August 19 and August 26, 2026.

HR staff know their own pay policies well. Still, each answer reflects the view of one person at one employer, and the report does not break results out by firm size. Firm size matters here.

Female HR professional standing in front of colleagues in a modern office.
The Selby Jennings survey questioned 500 U.S. finance HR professionals, rather than 500 company executives.

Jacob Summers, who heads tech recruiting at Selby Jennings, told Semafor that the practice is more common at fintech startups and smaller firms than at brand-name banks and trading houses.

So “Wall Street” in the headlines is shorthand. The giant banks most readers picture are not the main drivers of that 25%, at least not yet.

How Much Money Is Riding on Bonus Season

Bonuses are not a side dish in finance pay. The New York State Comptroller estimates that the average bonus for New York City securities employees reached a record $246,900 for 2025, up 6%.

The total pool hit $49.2 billion, and bonuses made up about 42% of securities industry wages. Before leaning on that figure, keep its limits in mind.

WALL STREET BONUS DATA | 2025
$246,900
Average annual bonus for New York City securities employees, according to the New York State Comptroller. Up 6% from the previous year.
  • It covers securities employees who work in New York City, not finance workers nationwide.
  • It excludes stock options and other deferred pay on which taxes were not withheld.
  • Adjusted for inflation, the bonus pool peaked in 2006, at $53.7 billion.

The 2026 numbers are still forecasts, not payouts. Compensation consultant Johnson Associates projected in May that incentive pay in investment and commercial banking would rise about 10%.

It also described a two-tier talent market in which AI-led roles command premiums, ThinkAdvisor reported.

Nobody Agrees Yet on What Good AI Use Looks Like

The Selby Jennings report admits the definitions are loose. Of its respondents, 16% do not know what “AI-enabled” means for the roles they hire for, and 31% say nobody internally can confidently evaluate AI candidates.

If firms struggle to judge AI skill in a job interview, judging it fairly at review time will not be easier.

Financial professionals reviewing employee performance charts and workplace analytics during a team meeting.
Financial firms are still working out how to measure the value of employees’ AI skills and productivity.

Measurement can also backfire. Business Insider reported in April that JPMorgan built dashboards ranking engineers by their use of tools such as GitHub Copilot, with about 70,000 provisioned users and 24,000 active ones as of March. The bank said the data guides AI investment, not formal reviews.

When the BBC examined AI-based performance reviews in September, it noted that Amazon had shut down an internal AI leaderboard after employees began giving the tools pointless tasks to climb the rankings.

Our view is simple. Counting prompts measures activity, and a bonus should pay for results.

Plans Are Running Ahead of Practice

PwC asked a different group a different question. Its 2026 Financial Services Workforce AI Survey, fielded in May, covered 1,004 director-level or higher leaders at U.S. financial services firms with at least $500 million in revenue.

Of those leaders, 91% said they are raising pay for employees with AI skills, and 58% said they will tie compensation directly to AI-enabled productivity.

Side by side, the two surveys show a clear gap. Senior leaders say they intend to pay for AI, while a quarter of HR respondents say their firm already does.

We would treat the PwC figure as the direction of travel and the Selby Jennings figure as where things stand now.

Did You Know?

Nearly eight in 10 leaders in the PwC survey expect their workforce to shrink by at least 20% over the next five years. The sector is already smaller. Federal payroll data show that the finance industry has cut 129,000 jobs since May 2025.

What a Bigger AI Bonus Does to Your Taxes

A larger bonus does not raise every payroll deduction equally. Social Security tax stops at a yearly cap, while Medicare tax applies to every dollar.

CPA Jason Ackerman explains why the 22% federal bonus withholding rate may not cover an employee’s final income tax liability.

Taxable Maximum

Taxable maximum: the most a worker can earn in a year that is subject to the 6.2% Social Security tax. It is $184,500 for 2026 and rises to $192,300 for 2027, according to the Social Security Administration 2027 fact sheet.

Here is our own example, using hypothetical figures. A worker with a $150,000 salary and a $50,000 AI-linked bonus paid in the same calendar year earns $200,000.

Social Security tax applies to the first $184,500, for a maximum of $11,439, and the remaining $15,500 is not taxed for Social Security.

Medicare tax of 1.45% applies to the full $200,000, or $2,900.

Example: $200,000 Total Annual Earnings
Base salary
$150,000
AI-linked bonus
$50,000
Total annual earnings
$200,000
Maximum Social Security tax (2026)
$11,439
Medicare tax at 1.45%
$2,900
Hypothetical example using 2026 payroll tax rates. Figures exclude other applicable taxes and deductions.

Bonus timing changes the math too. A payout that lands in early 2027 counts against the higher 2027 cap, not the 2026 one.

Why bonus tax withholding can look higher than the actual tax owed on the payment.

What to Do Before Your Next Review

If your firm has started asking about AI, do not wait for the review form to tell you how you will be judged. We would start with these five steps.

01
Ask your manager, preferably in writing, whether AI use is measured by activity, by output, or by both.
02
Keep a short log of work where AI saved time or caught an error, with dates and rough hours saved.
03
Describe results in business terms, which is also what the Selby Jennings report advises job seekers to do.
04
Find out what data the firm collects on your tool use and how long it keeps that data.
05
Keep your fundamentals visible. Over a quarter of respondents (27%) still rank passing interview assessments without AI as a highly sought qualification.

Compare any offer that promises a bigger AI-linked bonus against local costs. We looked at that tradeoff when we asked whether your job pays more in a higher-paying city.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Is the $246,900 average what a typical Wall Street worker receives?
Probably not. The figure is an average for New York City securities employees, and very large payouts at the top pull an average upward. The Comptroller does not publish a median, so the typical bonus is likely lower, and many operations and support staff receive far less.
2. When are Wall Street bonuses usually paid?
The Comptroller measures the traditional bonus season, which runs from December through March. Its estimate is based on personal income tax withholding trends, which is why the yearly figure arrives in late March.
3. Can my employer track how I use AI tools at work?
Generally, employers may monitor activity on company systems and devices. New York has required private employers since May 2022 to give written notice of electronic monitoring and collect employee acknowledgment. Rules differ by state, so check your employee handbook.
4. Are finance companies the only ones tying pay to AI?
No. Meta told employees that performance reviews starting in 2026 would assess their “AI-driven impact.” Google has also factored AI use into some software engineer reviews.
5. What happens if I overpay Social Security tax after switching jobs mid-year?
Each employer withholds Social Security tax separately up to the annual cap. If two employers together withheld more than the yearly maximum, you can claim the excess as a credit on your federal tax return.

Document What AI Contributes to Your Performance

For now, the Selby Jennings survey describes a quarter of finance employers, many of them smaller firms, writing AI into pay decisions, with a larger group still drafting the rules. The record $246,900 average bonus explains why workers are paying close attention.

Our advice is to treat AI as one line on your review, not the whole review, and to document what it actually delivered. The Comptroller usually publishes its bonus estimate in late March. The 2026 figure will cover the first year in which a measurable share of finance firms had AI rules on the books. If your firm has added an AI line to its review form, write to us.