The number that stopped us this quarter was 42%. The Federal Reserve Bank of New York, which tracks the labor market for recent college graduates, reports that about 42% of employed graduates ages 22 to 27 worked in jobs that typically do not require a bachelor’s degree in the second quarter of 2026.
Recent graduates also faced a 5.6% unemployment rate. The overall U.S. rate was 4.2% in September, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics jobs report.
A headline wage or job figure deserves to be taken apart before it is trusted. The 42% deserves the same treatment.
What the New York Fed Actually Counts
The New York Fed defines a recent graduate as someone ages 22 to 27 with a bachelor’s degree or higher, including master’s and professional degrees. The 42% covers only graduates who have jobs.
The New York Fed reports that 42% of employed recent college graduates work in occupations that typically do not require a bachelor’s degree.
View this post on Instagram
The classification depends on the occupation. The bank uses O*NET survey data on education requirements to decide whether an occupation typically calls for a degree.
Job titles are terrible little troublemakers. Two people with the same title can do very different work, so any measure built on occupation codes carries some fuzz.
In the New York Fed series, a graduate counts as underemployed when working in an occupation that typically does not require a bachelor’s degree, based on O*NET education survey data. The measure says nothing direct about pay, hours, or job satisfaction.
The 42% Is a Rounded Number With a Long History
A chart is never enough for us. We want the spreadsheet behind it, so we downloaded the monthly underemployment data file from the New York Fed. Each figure is a seasonally adjusted three-month moving average.
| Month | Recent graduates (22 to 27) | All graduates (22 to 65) |
|---|---|---|
| April 2001 (series low) | 36.6% | 31.7% |
| June 2012 | 45.2% | 34.6% |
| January 2020 | 41.3% | 33.5% |
| June 2020 | 38.1% | 31.8% |
| June 2023 | 40.1% | 33.3% |
| December 2025 | 42.3% | 34.4% |
| June 2026 | 42.0% | 33.7% |
The June 2026 reading was 41.95%, slightly below December 2025 and 1.8 points above June 2023, by my calculation. The series high, 48.4%, came in November 1992.
Treat the 2020 dip with caution. Underemployment fell when the pandemic hit, most likely because many low-wage jobs vanished, not because graduates suddenly found better work.
Why the Rate Has Crept Up Since 2023
Nobody has proven a single cause, and we get suspicious of anyone who claims one. The evidence points to several pressures at once.

- Slow hiring. Employers are adding few new workers, and graduates feel that first. We covered the pattern when job openings hit a five-month low in August.
- AI-exposed majors. A September 2026 Census Bureau working paper found that graduates from the most AI-exposed tenth of majors saw their odds of initial employment fall 5 percentage points after ChatGPT’s release, while starting earnings fell 13%. About half of that pay loss came from moves into lower-wage sectors such as restaurants and retail.
- An important limit. The AI finding applies to the most exposed majors. It does not explain the whole 42%, which stood at 41.3% in January 2020, years before ChatGPT existed.
Your Major Moves the Odds More Than the Headline Does
Whenever someone quotes the average salary for a job, the first question is which version of the job they mean. Majors deserve the same question.
The latest major-by-major figures from the New York Fed, based on 2024 Census data, put these fields at the top of the underemployment list.
- Criminal justice, 65.8%
- Performing arts, 63.9%
- Fine arts, 58.9%
- Leisure and hospitality, 58.1%
- Liberal arts, 54.6%
- Communications, 53.0%
At the other end, nursing sat at 9.7% and computer science at 16.5% in the 2023 figures that the St. Louis Fed reviewed.
Computer science shows why one number is never enough. Its graduates rarely land in non-degree jobs, yet the major posted a 7.0% unemployment rate in 2024, among the highest of any field.
First Jobs Have a Way of Becoming Careers
In 2024, the Burning Glass Institute and Strada published Talent Disrupted, which tracked graduates through their first decade of work.
It found 52% underemployed one year after graduation and 45% still underemployed ten years later.

The report relies on online career histories and measures graduates one year out, two reasons its figure runs higher than the New York Fed estimate.
Graduates who started underemployed were 3.5 times more likely to remain there a decade later.
The pull is understandable. Liking the people at work is a real reason to stay, and Americans stay with one employer for a median of 4.1 years, so a bridge job can quietly fill most of your twenties.
A Degree Still Pays, Just Not on Autopilot
The other half of the data matters just as much. Underemployment is real, but it does not cancel out the earnings advantage a degree still brings over time.

Unemployment for workers ages 22 to 34 without degrees sits near a two-decade low, as Newsweek reported from Burning Glass research.
The degree premium remains. In 2025, full-time workers 25 and older with a bachelor’s degree earned a median $1,578 a week, versus $966 for high school graduates, in BLS education data. By my math, that $612 weekly gap equals about $31,824 a year. The figures include underemployed graduates and exclude October 2025, lost to the federal shutdown.
How to Use These Numbers Before Picking a Major or a First Job
As we explained when comparing whether jobs really pay more in higher-paying cities, “pays more” and “leaves you better off” are different statements. The same goes for degrees. A few practical checks help.
- Look up your major’s underemployment rate next to its starting salary. The New York Fed publishes both.
- Get an internship or co-op before graduation, since the evidence on internships is unusually strong.
- Put an end date on any bridge job and write it down. My household spreadsheet has far too many tabs, but a deadline tab earns its place.
- Read the job description, not the title. A role can use your degree skills even when its occupation code says otherwise.
None of these steps guarantees a degree-level job, but each one shifts the odds in a slow-hiring market.
What to Watch Next
The New York Fed updates its graduate data quarterly, usually in February, May, August, and November, so third-quarter figures should arrive next month. We will be checking whether the rate climbs back above 42%, where it sat in late 2025, and whether unemployment for recent graduates finally drops below 5.6%.
Spreadsheets have no place on a family vacation. College decisions are a different matter. Whatever else goes into the choice, one tab belongs near the top, and it shows underemployment by major right beside starting pay.
Underemployment
Graduate unemployment
Next quarterly reading
Important Questions to Ask:
1. Is the New York Fed figure the same as the government’s U-6 underemployment rate?
No. The BLS U-6 rate counts the unemployed, involuntary part-timers, and people marginally attached to the labor force. The New York Fed measure only asks whether a graduate’s occupation typically requires a degree.
2. Are associate degree holders included in the 42%?
No. The series covers only bachelor’s degrees or higher, so associate degrees and certificates fall outside it.
3. Can I see underemployment rates for my state or city?
Not from this tracker. Its figures are national only, even though the bank serves the New York region.
4. How do recent graduates compare with young workers who never earned a degree?
Graduates still have the edge. In the first quarter of 2026, unemployment for people ages 22 to 27 without a four-year degree was 7.2%, versus 5.6% for graduates, Bloomberg Law reported.
5. Does the New York Fed consider its numbers official estimates?
No. The bank labels them research calculations, not official estimates of the New York Fed or the Federal Reserve System.
